Imitation might be the sincerest form of flattery, but Mansur Gavriel is far from charmed by Italian brands that the New-York based design duo, Rachel Mansur and Floriana Gavriel, claims have outright copied its ever-so-popular bucket bag.

Mansur Gavriel’s bucket bag was first produced four years ago, and since then, it’s a must-have accessories that usually forces shoppers to be put on a waitlist for months. Of course, the bucket bag silhouette is not a new one. However, the label has filed a lawsuit against multiple manufacturers, whom Mansur Gavriel says they’ve sent cease and desist letters to in the past, for continuing to sell bags that mimic their it-bag’s distinctive features. Beyond its minimal aesthetic, they include the cinched drawstring closure, the placement of a tiny metallic logo, and the adjustable metal-studded strap.

In order for Mansur Gavriel to win the case, the brand will have to prove that consumers, including those beyond the fashion-minded sphere, will find its version of the bag to be synonymous with the brand itself, which could be a challenge. We’ll just have to see how the battle of the bucket bags plays out in court.