There has been a lot of buzz around Kim Kardashian‘s KKW Fragrance release during the past week, with many asking what the Crystal Gardenia scent actually smells like. Coveteur got their hands on the Instagram-friendly fragrance, and put the new perfume to the test.

The site rounded up five editors to give their comment on the healing crystal-shaped scent, and opinions were divided. From “clean and minimal,” to “straight forward” and “smells like a tropical vacation,” it is hard to describe the Crystal Gardenia fragrance, but it is obvious that Kardashian’s first KKW Fragrance is a pleasant surprise.

Head over to the Coveteur to read the full reviews of the fresh, floral scent.